Business

Big banks slammed for credit card charges

January 25, 2010

Hidden details about the interest charged on partly-paid or overdue credit card balances is unfairly costing customers, consumer advocate group Choice says.

A study of 20 credit card companies showed the amount of interest charged on a credit card can depend as much on when a provider stops and starts charging interest and how fairly they apply interest-free days as the actual advertised interest rate.

American Express, Bankwest, Commonwealth Bank, ANZ and Westpac were named as the the most unfair credit card providers.

''Many consumers would be surprised to learn they could have two cards with exactly the same interest rate and use them in the same way yet have one charging twice as much interest than the other if they pay late,'' Choice spokesman Christopher Zinn said.

''The tricks of the trade make it much harder to compare the relative merits of different credit cards because the headline interest rate is only part of the story.''

Most credit card companies backdate their interest to the date of the purchase if a repayment is late, Choice said, meaning just one day late can result in higher interest being charged retrospectively for up to 55 days.

Partial repayments are also unlikely to stop that backdating occurring, Choice said.

For example if a customer were to underpay a $2000 bill by just $10, the extra interest would still be charged on the whole $2000.

Fairer credit card providers, such as Bendigo Bank, Heritage Building Society, Teachers Credit Union and some GE cards, only charge interest on the shortfall, Choice said.

Mr Zinn called on all credit card providers to use the same charging methods, and for customers to be aware of the finer details.

''It's a simple matter to tweak systems to employ fairer systems but while most customers don't understand the tricks they will inevitably continue,'' he said.

The Commonwealth Bank said in response to the Choice report that its products included low-interest rate cards and cards offering up to 55 days interest free.
 
The "comprehensive range of credit card options" enable customers to choose "the best and most cost-effective card based on their financial needs and personal circumstances".

Bankwest rejected the conclusions of the Choice report.
 
"We reject any suggestion that the interest calculation on our cards is unfair," said Adrian Bradley, spokesman for the Commonwealth-owned bank. "All the terms and conditions of all our products are clearly and precisely laid out for all customers.
 
"Bankwest is committed to remaining highly competitive and offering greater choice."

AAP, with Chris Zappone, BusinessDay

10 comments so far

  • Banks that pursue such premeditated unfair practices should have their licences revoked. It's not as if they're unaware that what they're doing is unconscionable - surely most banking execs have university degrees? Or was it permanent head damage from getting their PhDs?

    Commenter
    Talking Cents
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 8:34AM
  • Beware the REFUND! When fully paying out a month's balance I still received a hefty interest charge. When enquiring why, I learnt that the bank's rules were that the total amount "closing balance" is not the "balance owing". It is not the amount needed to be paid to incur no interest if there was a refund during the month. I was told that a refund is not a "payment". I bought a filing cabinet for about $300. The sales person stuffed the payment process and it was recorded twice - 2 payments of $300. She apologised and a refund of $300 was enacted immediately. So the bank extended the 2nd $300 credit for approximately 3 minutes. The monthly statement "closing balance"did not include the 2nd $300 charge. Silly me - fancy thinking the "closing balance" meant "balance owing" - which, of course is what we are meant to think. Instead, this little error by a salesperson and that 3 min credit of$300 to me by the bank of cost me quite a bit, and I wouldn't have found out about it if I was someone who just made monthly payments. And, of course, because they didn't consider the month fully paid up, I was charged interest on the whole balance for the month, and yes it was backdated to the beginning - the interest free days were wiped for that month. After much complaining the amount charged was reduced, but it still cost a quite a bit.

    The Lesson: if you have a refund in the month - pay the "closing balance" + the amount of the refund. Then you won't be charged interest for the refund amount - remember the bank doesn't consider a "refund" as a "payment" - it's a "credit" but not a "payment".

    Commenter
    Lucy
    Location
    NSW
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 9:11AM
  • The banks didn't heistate to call for the government to guarantee their deposits when the crisis hit.

    Now it is time to play the flip side of the coin. If the banks won't regulate themselves, it is time for the regulator to act.

    Commenter
    Goresh
    Location
    Brisbane
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 10:09AM
  • On the topic of cc fees, ANZ have a great scam going. Did you know the system deliberately allows you to overdraw your card by $100? The teller explained to me that it was to prevent the embarrassment of having the card rejected. Of course they'd charge $35 for the privilege. It wouldn't be so bad except that I was in the process of deliberately reducing my card limit at the time. So they were willing to lend me $3000, but if I reduce the limit to $2000 they'd let me have $2100 but it would cost me $35 for the last $100. When I said no thanks, please reject it at $2000 like I asked and forget about the overdraw they said that the system wouldn't allow that! So could I set the limit at $2100 and eliminate the $100 'leeway'? Nope, that would allow me $2200 with a fee for the last $35. I'd rather be embarrassed, but apparently that's not an option.

    Thanks for living in MY world ANZ.

    Commenter
    jd
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 10:19AM
  • ANZ run the biggest scam of all. On ANZ VISA Card, the minium monthly payment is due 14 days after accounts is issued, and if you are late by 1 day, then get slugged a $35 late payment fee.
    When queried ANZ, was told I could change to a different card type, with payment due 28 days after statement date. All cards should be consistant with payement date

    Commenter
    John
    Location
    Helensvale Qld
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 10:57AM
  • Nothing like a bit of personal responsibility.

    As far as I'm aware banks aren't registered charities. If you don't want to pay charges then pay your account off in full every month and don't go over your limit. It's not exactly complicated.

    Commenter
    Doctor
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 10:56AM
  • Hi all,

    Credit cards are a great way for a bank to make money.... people mainly use them as they like to spend more than they earn. If you dont like the fees then close it, by law banks have to provide all the relevent info and product schedules, if you dont read the info and think you shouldnt have to then you shouldnt complain when you get fees!

    Goresh the banks didnt beg the government for the gurantee, it was brought out to stabalize market fear and give a false assurance that everything is ok....

    An honou fee is introduced as the next person complains that they should be able to avoid the embassesment, again this you would find in the info they give you when you open one, remember those documents that you threw in the bin???

    When a bank brings out a product, the aim is to make money and offer a deal that may be different and ppl will take up. It has to go via their legal department to make sure no laws are being broken and that its within apra regulations.

    Instead of jumping up and down about fees and conspiracy theories that the bank is out to get you try looking over what you are taking to make sure you understand the full terms and conditions.

    And last of all dont go into the bank and yell at the person who earns the least money in the company and who doesnt get a say. There is no need to ruin their day because you are iggnorant and refuse to read and understand something you signed several times for.

    Educate yourself!

    Commenter
    maxpower
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 11:20AM
  • people, throw your credit cards away.

    they are evil.

    Commenter
    blue
    Location
    bris
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 12:12PM
  • JD - ANZ arent the only ones that charge you for going over the "limit" (definition: "The point, edge, or line beyond which something cannot or may not proceed"). Like you the bank that I have my CCs with allows me to purchase past my limit (apparently for my benefit) and have advised me that I should keep an eye on my a/c if I think I'll go over. In their defence I had my fee waivered the first time this happened to me and after they explained that they couldnt stop transactions going over the limit I have kept a keen eye on my CC a/cs and have topped up my cards with cash when necessary.

    The system that is used to calculate interest on CCs has been in place for 20 years (give or take) - ever since I have had CCs. What banks do seems to be wrong and I hate it (and banks) but I accept thats how they function. Its up to CC users to be responsible for their a/cs.

    My bank is very cooperative. I have called them and explained that I made a mistake and paid my a/c a day late. They can see from my very good tract record that I usually pay on time and more than I need to each time. Once I explain the situation they fix it so I dont pay interest.

    Instead of complaining, make a stand by leaving banks and take your business elsewhere like a credit union. Otherwise deal with it! :)

    Commenter
    CreditUnionsForTheWin
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 1:23PM
  • By "comprehensive range of credit card options" I think they mean a confusing range that will never have precisely the features you want. Face it, there are only so many features a credit card should have - making up new combinations of some of those features is nothing more than profiteering.

    Commenter
    Wayne Kerr
    Date and time
    January 25, 2010, 1:15PM

Make a comment

You are logged in as [Logout]

All information entered below may be published.

Error: Please enter your screen name.

Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Please enter your comment.

Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

Post to

You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

Thank you

Your comment has been submitted for approval.

Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

More Related Coverage

Unfair credit card companies named

Hidden details about interest charged on partly paid or overdue credit card balances are unfairly costing customers, consumer advocate group Choice says.