Business

Elders statement puts heat on Ludwig

Adele Ferguson
July 6, 2011

The move by Elders to put out a statement to the ASX putting a figure the cost to its business of the live cattle ban will crank up the pressure on the minister for agriculture Joe Ludwig to resign or be sacked.

Elders shares slumped more than 1.3 per cent to 39 cents on a day when the market was flat on the grim news that the Gillard Government’s decision to suspend live cattle exports to Indonesia could cost it up to $7.3 million.

For a business that lost $14.6 million in the first six months to March 31, on revenue of $1.08 billion, it is a cost it can ill afford.

Elders said the direct impact of the suspension on the company in June was $1 million and it would cost a further $2.2 million with the flow-on effects on northern Australian trading and lower prices, taking the total cost in June to $3.2 million.

Other companies, including the listed Australian Agricultural Company, have come forward and downgraded profits, but the killer punch is the damage it has done – and will do – to relations with one of our most important trading partners, Indonesia, which is also a big importer of wheat and cotton. That is yet to play out, but the longer a resolution is not found, the bigger the cost will be.

While the nation was horrified at the video of animal cruelty in some Indonesian abattoirs exposed by Four Corners, the industry has become a political football, with the welfare of animals left unloaded at Port Hedland one of the last things on politicians' minds.

The Gillard government needs to act fast to reopen abattoirs that are of an acceptable standard. There also needs to be a rapid increase in the quality of some of the B-grade abattoirs to an accredited standard. And it needs to sack Ludwig if he isn’t willing to resign.

adele.ferguson@fairfaxmedia.com.au

29 comments

  • No surprise that another trade union hacker hasn't got a clue about running a business. Priced out of world markets by unrealistic wage demands and concessions, the Gillard carbon tax will be the final nail in the country's coffin. Pity it's not hers.

    Commenter
    John
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 2:49PM
  • I believe this is a form of emotional blackmail. Just like the farmer in W.A. who decided he was going to destroy his cattle and then didn't.

    All farmers have a responsibility in the live cattle trade to follow through on the end product.

    All farmers have a responsibility and those associations who have received funding from the farmers have a responsibility. Perhaps the Directors of those organisations should be financially responsible.

    Australians cannot allow our live exports to be treated like they were ever again.

    The farmers need to be part of the solution instead of expecting others to fix the problem.

    Commenter
    waterhen
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 2:59PM
  • Gorblimey it's not often that I'll side with an incumbent minister but I wonder what it is that Joe's done wrong. Can we all remind ourselves what the catalyst for these events was? It was the appalling, unconscionable treatment of Australian livestock at the hands of poorly trained, badly equipped (and in some cases borderline sadistic) slaughtermen in a medieval abbatoir in Indonesia. Ludwig put a stop to that, albeit belatedly.

    All this barbarismtook place on the MLA's watch - the body that is allegedly responsible for overseeing the welfare of animals shipped OS by this trade. You want someone to string up? Look no further than that organisation.

    As this journalist notes, this has become a political football. How abysmal. The slimebags in Canberra and elsewhere looking to make political capital out of this disgrace - which first and foremost is nothing but a massive embarrassment for our allegedly compassionate nation - should be ashamed of themselves. If Elders, or any other corporation is losing money as a result of this cruel trade then excuse me, but stiff s**t.

    Commenter
    daveinbalmain
    Location
    balmain
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:03PM
  • Perhaps the livestock industry should have taken a closer interest in the fate of the animals it loaded onto ships. Its a bit rich to turn a blind eye to the shocking abuse that awaited them, then complain when someone steps in to call a halt.

    Commenter
    frazzle
    Location
    Epping
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:06PM
  • Re - waterhen
    Emotional blackmail. What do you think the 4 corners report was?
    Why didn't they show the majority of Indonesian abbatoirs that deal with Australian cattle that operate to our standards?

    Commenter
    Geoff
    Location
    west of the great divide
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:12PM
  • Just like the rest of the Labor mob and the idiotic Greens, none of them have had a job in the real world and not one of them would be employable in the real world
    No wonder Australia is in such a bloody mess, Australia deserves better than this and we must have an election before this lot can do anymore damage to this country.
    This madness must end and end quickly.

    Commenter
    alan
    Location
    sydney
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:14PM
  • The adage "how to get into small business, start off in big business and elect a labor govt." Says it about the current Govt, Ludwig would have got any job it were not for his father.The power broker in Qld, the same could be said for Gillard and staying in her job. She has to please Bill Ludwig to keep her job

    Commenter
    john
    Location
    tsv
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:14PM
  • Ludwig should resign. He has single handedly transformed a horrible but managable animal welfare issue into an unmitigated economic and political disaster.
    I think Kevin Rudd would agree.
    @ waterhen. what was the four corners programme if not emotional blackmail? Cattle may yet be shot as the only humane alternative to starvation. Thats not emotional blackmail its the reality of the current situation.
    Ludwigs response to the threat of cattle being shot was to ask CENTERLINK to see if it could help.Ridiculous.

    Commenter
    Brendan.
    Location
    Ballarat
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:17PM
  • waterhen @ 2.59 The statement you have made is completely stupid, you would have to be a green voter as well as a labor voter to think like that go out and work on a catle station for a year or two

    Commenter
    Chris K
    Location
    Brisbane
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:20PM
  • Brendan. | Ballarat - July 06, 2011, 3:17PM

    We could of course slaughter them in more humane condition in Australia and release them onto the domestic market, couldn't we? In a free market, if you lose one source of revenue you look for another, not beg for a handout

    Commenter
    daveinbalmain
    Location
    balmain
    Date and time
    July 06, 2011, 3:32PM

More comments

Comments are now closed

More Related Coverage

Elders to 'lose millions' from cattle export ban

6 Jul Agricultural products distributor Elders Ltd says the live cattle export suspension to Indonesia will cost the company up to $7.3 million.

AACo seeks loan for cattle pool

6 Jul Australia’s biggest live cattle exporter wants the federal government to back a scheme that would throw a financial lifeline to Northern Territory beef producers hamstrung by the trade ban to Indonesia.