Business

Forget the tax, mining investment powers on

August 26, 2010

When the resources industry was threatening a capital strike during the resources rent tax argy-bargy, it was quietly planning a massive surge in investment.

Today’s Australian Bureau of Statistics capital expenditure survey for the June quarter shows miners in that fraught period were expecting to invest a massive $54.8 billion this financial year up, up 29 per cent on their actual 2009-10 capex and a whopping 48 per cent higher than the corresponding expectations survey for that year.

What’s more, the expectations for capex this year are up by 12 per cent on the estimate made in the March quarter. Whatever the mining industry was saying, whatever projects were frozen, the big private investment surge the Reserve Bank and Treasury are relying on just got bigger.

And, crucially, it’s not just the resources industry that plans to increase investment this year – capex expectations are up across the board in marked contrast to the dip in business confidence surveys over the past couple of months. This may be a case of watch what I do, not what I say.

The estimate for total private sector capital expenditure for 2010-11 is $123.3 billion, up 17.5 per cent on the March quarter estimate, 24 per cent higher than the equivalent estimate for the year just finished, 16 per cent more than capex for last financial year.

Even the manufacturing industry, feeling the pressure of the stronger Australian dollar, intends to spend with forecast capex this financial year of $14.1 billion, up 12 per cent from the March quarter survey.

The broad “other selected industries” reckon they’ll spend $54.4 billion by June 30, 25 per cent more than they were thinking in the March quarter. Intended spending on buildings and structures is up 30 per cent in just three months while equipment, plant and machinery is 21 per cent. The two-star performers in the subsections were rental, hiring and real estate services and transport, postal and warehousing, both up 34 per cent.

There’s often a slip between expectations and realised expenditure, but over the past five years the June quarter estimate for the year has either been exceeded or finished up being about right.

This should be a major boost for Australian business confidence when media is dominated by the woes of North Atlantic economies, cautious reporting season commentary and never mind what passes for local politics.

It has been the RBA’s forecast and the federal government’s hope that the private sector investment would arrive to pick up the lull created by the phasing out of stimulus spending. Today’s stats say that forecast and hope are not just on track, but perhaps being exceeded.

Having spent yesterday at the DMC Skills Australia annual conference, these capex expectations underline the skills shortage challenge ahead. There’s already effectively full employment in many of the key trades.

The monetary policy bears will seize on this welcome growth as a reason for predicting higher interest rates – but those forecasts may not come true for a while yet. Whoever emerges as Prime Minister, the 457 temporary work visa system and permanent skilled migration schemes remain happily in place to ease a problem that would otherwise both cause inflation and prevent projects starting.

And the RBA, on a roll with its forecasting lately, believes Australian consumers will remain wary for the next year, increasing their savings ratio rather than pouring all their extra earnings into the retailers’ pockets.

Looking through Woolworths results, the better retailers will do very nicely anyway. The Woolworths figures are a reminder to commentators to look for the quality, rather than just quantity. The knee-jerk reactions to sales figures failed to allow for the quality of the retailers’ management and their protection of profitability.

While hands were being wrung about the impact of the stimulus now missing from consumers’ wallets, Woolworths still increased its gross profit margin from 25.66 to 25.91 per cent. The supermarket gross margin improved by 46 points to 24.51 per cent.

There’s a message there: if Wesfarmers wants to get hairy-chested about Coles competition, Woolworths has the firepower to deal with it. And both parties know that. Woolworths is a business that makes a 77 per cent return on funds employed.

Woolworths also pointedly reminded analysts that Big W, the business that most felt that lack of cash splash this time, had still outperformed all other department stores over the three-year period.

And some of those capex expectations numbers belong to the dominant retailer – investing more money in its supply chain infrastructure in a project that it expects to deliver lower costs over the next five years.

Yes, there are reasons to be cautious about the economy, but there also are reasons to be optimistic. Watch the money, rather than the rhetoric.

Michael Pascoe is a BusinessDay contributing editor

13 comments

  • The rather gaping flaw in this logic is the presumption that this planned capital investment would been implemented in a world where the governtment exppropriated 40% of the planned projects.

    Commenter
    Goose with the golden eggs save for now
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 1:15PM
  • If Gillard teams up with the Greens to form a minority government - that increases the mining tax, you can bet that the dollar will fall like a lead stone.

    Commenter
    Comrade
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 1:29PM
  • what crocodile tears from a bunch of WA billionaires we did witness during the election campaign over the RSPT/MSPT. to think that members of the public were duped by their wailing and blathering about having to pay more tax on a finite resource with the proceed going to assist all Australians, them included.
    I wonder how many people know that when WA joined the Commonwealth that the rest of the States carried them for decades through tax handouts and other assistance measure? all we now want is a little in return.
    But i don't expect the cow boys and girls of WA to even consider the rest of the country, they have eyes for their own greed and lifestyles.just

    Commenter
    rank one
    Location
    canberra
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 1:32PM
  • First, the govt would never have had 40% of any project, but 40% of profits beyond forecast profit levels the miners put forward when negotiating their reseource rental deals from us the taxpayers....

    Second, clearly the miners were again blatantly lying about the supposed dire situation and witrhdrawal of investments. Blatantly lying. And we the the taxpayers are once again the stooges, with miners thrusting their greed ridden hands deep deep down our pockets and grasping the last of what they can find.

    I believe the word is *rapacious*...

    And where will they be when the last of our resources are depleted? Well by then they will have sold us out to the Chinese govt and will living well on our cost....

    Commenter
    Goose is really a goose...
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 1:38PM
  • I thought the mining companies over played their hand a bit on the mining tax. Although Rudd was on his last legs, the mining tax was the straw that broke the camel's back. What I found very disturbing was the RIO chief making comments in the UK "The tax had set up the prospect of a long period of uncertainty which was corrosive to new investment. From my own perspective, this is my number one sovereign risk issue on a global basis," Rio Tinto's chief executive Tom Albanese said. Hang on a minute, sovereign risk in Australia being a big problem? Hey Tom, don't you mine for diamonds in Zimbabwe? Zimbabwe, the country that removed white farmers from their farms. I can't remember when the Australian government force ably removed farmers from their family farms. I reckon it is time Tom pulled his horns in as if he feels that he was the man who removed Kevin Rudd then we need to see how it is possible that a multinational mining company can so much power over our democratically elected Prime Minister.

    Commenter
    Richo
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 2:04PM
  • Goose with the golden eggs save for now and Comrade: With due respect, I suspect you either work in the mining industry or have no idea how the world works. Mining billionaires would no doubt like to use the word "expropriate" etc to describe the mining "tax". But really, who is expropriating who? I think the mining billionaires and fellow miners are actually the ones expropriating resources the Australian people own. Imagine a world where someone could go into a factory or a farm and instead of paying what the factory owner or the farmer want to charge (ie. costs + a reasonably profit margin), they can just take the manufactured products or the produce and pay whatever it wants (say one dollar), would that be fair? In the business work, it is all supply and demand, and no one from the so called "liberals" would say it would be wrong if the factory owner or the farmer can charge whatever price it is if the market conditions permit (that is there is demand). So in this instead, what is wrong with the Australian people (equivalent to the farmer or factory owner), raising its price it charges on resources it owns? Stop seeing this as a "tax" on profits - the issue is not this. It is different to tax on a bank. Miners are having the general ill-informed public who listens to no more than talkback radio believe that this is some sort of illegal government intervention of their business rights. I'm sorry, I think it is the other way around. Wake up people.

    Commenter
    Tom
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 2:18PM
  • if labour gets in the miners will leave the country. George Bush is a good leader. The Iraq war is a good thing that will run smoothly. The sharemarket will be abck at 6300 by the end of the year (2009). All rubbish Ive heard from right leaning economists / liberal voters. Now a tax, like everyone has to pay will cripple them. just as ridiculous as the previous statements. But then Ive never heard an economist who got anything right.

    Commenter
    smilingjack
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 2:56PM
  • "If Gillard teams up with the Greens to form a minority government - that increases the mining tax, you can bet that the dollar will fall like a lead stone."

    Comrade | Melbourne - August 26, 2010, 1:29PM

    You can forget about the mining tax Comrade. It will not happen without the support of the three amigos.

    Commenter
    Jezz
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 3:54PM
  • Get over the mining tax issue. The big boys who will pay it have. Look at depth of investment confidence in this article. Makes a nice change.

    Commenter
    thinking
    Location
    Brisbane
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 4:42PM
  • How farsical... That we the Australian public are held at ransome by the mining companies who make billions of dollars in profit through the exploitation of our natural resources is incredible. The mining tax will not stop the mining companies from investing in our natural resources it's not as if they can pack up shop and mine uranium in the UK for example they can't WHY? because there is no uramium in the UK or gas or gold. However Australia has plenty for the moment at least the thing about natural resources is that it can only be mined once so why would we say no to a greater share of the profit that will benefit us and future generations. Afterall when the miners have packed up and gone they leave behind nothing but waste and in areas that were once rich farming land are turned into desolate wastelands that will never produce so much as weed for hundreds if not thousand of years.
    Poor Mining companies i think not.

    Commenter
    noreasons
    Location
    sydney
    Date and time
    August 26, 2010, 4:50PM

More comments

Comments are now closed

More Related Coverage

Business investment in surprise retreat

26 Aug Capital spending surprisingly fell for a second consecutive quarter in three months to June 30, marking the first back-to-back falls in more than three years.

Rio's Albanese warns of uncertain outlook

26 Aug Rio Tinto CEO Tom Albanese says uncertainties are on the horizon from the GFC, the government's proposed mining tax and climate change.