Business

Brisbane's house price surge 'an illusion'

Christine Kellett
January 28, 2010

Property analysts say a seven per cent surge in Brisbane house prices last year is not a true reflection of capital growth.

The Australian Property Monitors House Price Report, released yesterday, showed the median house price jumped from $413,767 to $445,562 in the 12 months to December, helped by a strong, three percent rise in values in the last quarter of 2009.

Unit values experienced more conservative growth of 1.8 per cent over the year, and actually fell by 1.4 per cent in the December quarter – the only sector in the country to go backwards.

----------------------------
Brisbane, coasts among world's most unaffordable
Inflation low but interest rates to rise
OPINION: Grey skies bring economic spin
----------------------------

While the rise caught many off guard yesterday, Australian Property Monitors said median house price growth in Brisbane was still well below the national average of 12.1 per cent, and far less than the Melbourne housing market, which logged a whopping 18.5 increase in prices over the year.

But property analysts have warned against panic, saying the figures have been skewed by strong sales in only one sector of the market – the luxury end  - which held up strongly against the global financial crisis.

RP Data’s national research director, Tim Lawless, said the anticipated effects of the first-home buyers’ grant wind-back late last year had also artificially inflated the Brisbane median.

''The figures released by APM are unexpectedly high and are likely to reflect a change in the types of properties that are transacting rather than true capital growth,” Mr Lawless said.
 
''A resurgence of interest in higher priced properties combined with the fall back of first home buyers is likely to have played a role in inflating the latest growth figures.''

RP Data will release its RP Data-Rismark Index tomorrow, which it claims takes into account transactional bias.

Funds manager and advisory firm Rismark International’s chief executive officer Christopher Joye said the company’s  own data would  ''provide a substantially more conservative picture of Australia’s housing market conditions''.

''The median price indices are being artificially boosted by the fading of first time buyers and the return of upgraders buying more expensive homes,'' Mr Joye said.

''The true rates of capital gains across Australia are substantially less than those reported by median price providers.''

Yesterday’s figures came within hours of the release of a damning survey of international housing markets which ranked South-East Queensland among the most unaffordable places to live in the world.

The Gold and Sunshine coasts scored higher than New York and London in the unaffordability stakes, followed closely by Brisbane.

The annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey examined 272 markets in six countries, including Australia, the US, UK, Canada, Ireland and New Zealand, and compared median house prices with median yearly household incomes.

Inflation rose a modest 2.1 per cent in 2009 - or 0.5 per cent int he December quarter - which has economists predicting interest rates will almost certainly rise this year.

17 comments

  • What is driving these prices?
    It can't be inflation- this is at a low
    It can't be low interest rates- the only way is up
    It can't be increasing wages- house prices have inflated well in excess
    It can' t be more infrastructure located close by or improved quality of the homes- we are talking half a million dollar dogboxes
    It can't be immigration and demand- QLD has always had an influx from NSW and VIC, and prices are high there too
    It can't be first home buyers- they can't afford a half million dollar home, and they buy the cheap homes...

    So what is propping this up? Might be nothing. And then the bubble will BURST!

    Commenter
    Bubble
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 9:28AM
  • doesnt take a genius to work it out mate.

    supply and demand.

    Commenter
    blue
    Location
    bris
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 9:39AM
  • doesn't take a genius to work it out mate.
    It's an asset bubble.

    Who are buying these houses when their wages can't cover it? Oh that's right, 110% property value loan on on the basis of an inflated property price.

    If ONE THING goes wrong, all hell will break loose.

    Commenter
    Bubble
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 10:22AM
  • We have the government waxing lyrical about how well they have handled the global financial crisis, but what they have been keeping quiet is this ticking timebomb. As a nation we are mortgaged to the eyeballs and maxed out on our credit cards. Expect big problems in 2011 as the interest rate rises which we all know must come this year start to impact on people's cost of living.

    Commenter
    tim-e
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 10:58AM
  • just whs wages cant cover it?

    i can, my neighbours can, my whole suburb seems to be affording it quite nicely.

    perhaps its you and few others who cant. to bad for you.

    were doing great.

    Commenter
    blue
    Location
    bris
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 11:46AM
  • Re: Bubble - January 28, 2010, 9:28AM
    "What is driving these prices?"

    It's the Rudd government allowing foreigners to purchase residential property without gaining approval from the Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB), most of which are bringing their millions from China.

    This is all a "catch 22", as it may keep the median house prices increasing, but will make it much harder for young Aussies to buy into the market, which will probably leave for other countries such as NZ (no stamp duty tax, no capital gains tax) or US (when their economy picks up & with cheaper homes with loans @ 5% fixed over 30 years with tax deductible interest payments).

    Commenter
    no-higher-taxes
    Location
    melbourne
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 11:54AM
  • I guess young people can take comfort in the fact that no housing bubble has ever been maintained long term anywhere in the world. US, UK, Japan, Dubai, Spain, Ireland, Iceland, Hong Kong ... all bubbles ... all crashed.

    Commenter
    Michael K
    Location
    Brisbane
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 11:50AM
  • what bubble? a nice inner city suburban home in one of the worlds most livable citys is always going to be out of the reach of more than a few people, If you want a cheap place, go out to logan or springfield.

    The housing crashed in the USA not from a bubble but from irresponsible lending, defaulting, causing an OVERSUPPLY of propertys, pushing values down, equity falling away, leading to more people seeing it being more financially viable to abandon their homes. America has unique laws that allow people to walk away from mortgages with no consequences.

    That was not a bubble, a bubble is a morons way of explaining events they know nothing about. Its not going to happen here as our circumstances and laws are much different and lending practices much tighter.

    Commenter
    blue
    Location
    bris
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 1:53PM
  • In the early '90s the US was in the same position as we are in now. Rising house prices, young people finding themselves in the queue with the disadvantaged and destitute at the Dept. Housing/Fannie Mae looking for a place to live. They don't have an affordability problem now!

    The characters and setting might be different, but the plot is the same. The same types come out and say they can defy economic gravity. When prices move out of range of the masses, and demand seemingly uncouples from supply, there is something very wrong.

    We have been here before- in the early 1980 the Australian house price bubble burst and prices went through the floor. We are now overdue for a crash in the house prices dept.

    I'll buy your house when the market crashes. Just you wait.

    Commenter
    Bubble
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 2:34PM
  • Blue: How do you explain the crash of UK housing prices then?? Or Japan?? Both with an undersupply?

    Commenter
    Michael K
    Location
    Brisbane
    Date and time
    January 28, 2010, 2:45PM

More comments

Comments are now closed