Business

Why jobs could be going, going, gone

Richard Webb
January 29, 2012
<p></p>

Job seekers outside of the mining industry are likely to face a much tougher time this year.

AUSTRALIA'S unemployment rate is heading towards a nine-year high of 6 per cent, economists say, with some industries preparing to slash staff and other industries suffering gradual job erosion.

The manufacturing, retail, construction and finance industries are all set to shed labour. At best, this means tepid jobs growth in the economy overall - less than the net 15,000 new jobs needed every month to keep the unemployment rate stable. And at worst, potentially the loss of up to a net 25,000 jobs during the year.

It's not just high-profile job cuts that will cause this expected rise in the unemployment rate, either. While there has been much debate about the 350 jobs to be axed at Toyota and forecast of a potential 7000 job losses over the next two years in the banking industry, in some industries, such as retail and farming, the workforce is being gradually eroded.

The latest industry jobs figures show that 44,800 jobs were lost in the manufacturing industry in the six months to the end of November, but 29,800 were also lost in agriculture and a further 28,100 jobs in retail.

On the booming side of our two-speed economy, the mining industry employs a relatively small 2 per cent of the total workforce, a fifth of those in healthcare. So while mining is expanding rapidly, the number of jobs it is creating - 41,400 in the six months to the end of November - is still less than in healthcare, which is growing to service our increasingly ageing population.

Besa Deda, chief economist at St George Bank, says the jobs market is sluggish at best right now and that the reason the unemployment rate hasn't spiked is because the workforce participation rate has been falling. People have been giving up looking for work, which has kept the lid on the percentage of people out of work - you can't be out of work if you are not looking for it, say the statisticians.

Ms Deda expects the jobs market to get worse.

''Employment is going to be pretty soft, and we expect the unemployment rate to rise to 6 per cent and could even break through it,'' she says.

''Employers are reticent to start hiring given the global backdrop, while manufacturers are under pressure from the strong $A and credit growth is very weak for the finance sector. I think these global worries will continue and we could lose jobs on a net basis.''

Unemployment last peaked at 5.9 per cent in June 2009 at the height of the global financial crisis, and was last at 6 per cent or above in 2003.

Macquarie Bank senior economist Brian Redican says the pressures on the jobs market that surfaced in 2011 have intensified, which is worrying given that last year generated a net zero jobs for the year as a whole.

But he expects 2012 to be a year of two halves, with unemployment to rise in the first six months and then for interest rate cuts to provide stability to the jobs market during the second half. Mr Redican expects the Reserve Bank to cut interest rates next month by 0.25 percentage points, and again before mid-year.

''We think the unemployment rate could rise towards 6 per cent by mid-year but to stabilise around then,'' he says. ''The risk though is that monetary policy is not as effective this time around - households are a lot less confident and may decide to repay their mortgages more quickly rather than boosting spending.''

Mr Redican says a pick-up in building approvals will be the first sign the reduction in the cash rate is going to do its job.

Phil O'Donaghoe, senior economist at Deutsche Bank, is also looking for a rate cut next month and a follow up before July. He says this will keep the unemployment rate at 5.5 per cent, partly because he believes the participation rate will continue to fall.

''The big picture for Australia is still strong, and demand for labour is high here in comparison to other countries,'' he says. ''Yes, the participation rate has fallen to 65.2 per cent, but at the start of 2000 it was at 63.5 per cent, so it's still higher than we were a decade ago.''

But Mr O'Donaghoe says a soft labour market will give soft wages growth and he forecasts 4.2 per cent growth in average wages this year, against 4.6 per cent in 2011.

Alarm bells are already ringing for some industries. Leon Carter, national secretary of the Financial Services Union, has called meetings with the big banks over the next fortnight to find out what's going on in the banking sector.

''There's been plenty of speculation around, almost goading the banking industry to lop jobs off in the thousands, and the worrying thing is that no one is doing anything to allay these fears,'' he says.

Mr Carter says the big difference between the manufacturing and finance is that the manufacturers are shedding labour to restore profitability, while the banking majors are still making huge profits.

20 comments

  • It will be interesting to see how many people blame Gillard for this.

    The reasons given in the article are global financial problems and the strong Australian dollar.

    As a teacher returning to to classes this week, I hope my students read this.

    Commenter
    HiLo
    Location
    Date and time
    January 29, 2012, 9:59AM
  • Healthcare and Social Services are now our 2nd biggest employer. This tells you a lot about the health of our "fake" economy as while both noble, neither of these "industries" actually makes or exports anything. Menwhile our unemployement rate is going up and our tax base is shrinking. Our money goes round and round....this while real economies (think China) make all the things that bring all the profit.

    I do not believe anything that Swan or Gillard or Shorten tell me about the health of our economy. Like our 2nd biggest employing industry, it too is very sick.

    Commenter
    sophie
    Location
    melbourne
    Date and time
    January 29, 2012, 10:36AM
  • Not "could be", are going. The sudden huge influx of capital has distorted the exchange rate so suddenly that many businesses either won't have any time to adjust or like the banks can't resist the 90+% saving on wages in the Philippines, China and India.

    Any job that can be done remotely will be off-shored. Count on it. And that includes a large percent of white collar jobs. You didn't think you were really worth $150K a year did you? Someone will do your job better for $15K per year and live like a king.

    Unemployment in Australia could double within two years. What's that going to do to house prices?

    Commenter
    Allan
    Location
    Prahran
    Date and time
    January 29, 2012, 10:46AM
    • Bring 'em down, I guess. And that can only be a good thing for most Australians.

      Commenter
      HiLo
      Location
      Date and time
      January 29, 2012, 10:58AM
    • What's that going to do to house prices?

      Well, hopefully they will go down so more people can buy them. That's the idea.

      Commenter
      JoeF
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      January 29, 2012, 11:07AM
    • So how come the UNIONS and the LABOR GOVT can not see this, when most of us can! Why are they taxing, over-regulating and squeezing employers to within an inch of their life (think Fair Work Australia, the WHS Bill, the new Mining Tax, the Carbon Tax....) this while most of our real jobs disappear and are replaced by the likes of social work, counseling, the welfare industry, public service jobs, caring for refugees......none of which can actually support an economy or generate a tax base. Are the unions and Labor that blind - or is it that they just do not care about Australias future?

      Commenter
      mimi
      Location
      melbourne
      Date and time
      January 29, 2012, 11:12AM
    • Mimi: "So how come the UNIONS and the LABOR GOVT can not see this, when most of us can!"

      Ah, yes, blame the unions. Without, of course, any suppoting evidence.

      As a matter of fact, the unions CAN see the evolving facts before everyone's eyes. We don't, however, think the answer is to cut wages till they reach the level of, say, the Philippines or Malaysia.

      The unions have two responses to this situation - one good, the other bad. The bad response is to call for a return to protectionism. It's a losing strategy since it relies on the goodwill of employers to pass the benefits on to their workforces. And, as has been demonstrated countless times over the years, the touching faith in the goodwill of bosses is bitterly disappointed. The only thing that bosses know about goodwill, it seems, is when it appears as an asset on their balance sheets.

      The good reaction of unions to the intensification of international labour market competition is to support the developing union movement in Asia. Worldwide, there are now more members of independent democratic trade unions than at any prevous time in history. We need to take this support to a whole new level and help the workers of Asia fight for their rights. Eitther the workers of Asia can force their wages and conditions up much closer to ours, or ours will be driven down much closer to theirs.

      Which option would YOU vote for?

      Commenter
      Greg Platt
      Location
      Brunswick
      Date and time
      January 29, 2012, 11:32AM
    • We found one!

      Alan;s an employer who doesn't believe in Fair Work conditions and Workplace Health and Safety, or refugees.

      If we don't have our standards, we might as well move to a third world country.

      Commenter
      HiLo
      Location
      Date and time
      January 29, 2012, 11:46AM
  • The strong dollar is decimating not only the manufacturing industries.

    Any job done on a computer in an office can be moved to a country with cheaper labour costs. Hundreds of thousands of university graduates in Asia are able to do them. Ironically, the new broadband network, which will cost Australian taxpayers $40 billions, will make the export of australian jobs even easier.

    The government, but mainly the RBA are to blame for not defending the dollar. Every smart country wants their currency to depreciate these days. The US, Japan, Switzerland, China, Brasil, to name a few, are actively devaluing, or putting ceilings on their currencies.

    We live in fools paradise. Cheap holidays and cheap gadgets made overseas are blinding us.

    Commenter
    JoeF
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    January 29, 2012, 11:04AM
  • Yep, the RBA and Labor have royally screwed up the economy. They've built up a housing bubble, worst than those seen in other English speaking nations, and now they have crippled any useful industry.
    When mining starts to tank this year due to Chinese contraction we will all be in for a rude awakening,

    Commenter
    Reality
    Location
    Brisbane
    Date and time
    January 29, 2012, 11:04AM

More comments

Comments are now closed

More Related Coverage

Strong dollar claims jobs at Holden

2 Feb Holden will cut up to 140 jobs from its Adelaide car plant in the latest of a series of job losses in the local car industry.