Executive Style

Prime drops lack passion

David Prestipino
February 19, 2010
Passion pop... Kevin Rudd's taste in wine is distinctively uninspiring and bland.

Passion pop... Kevin Rudd's taste in wine is distinctively uninspiring and bland.

Winestein uncorked

When the Senate last month laid bare our Prime Minister's wine cupboard, we got a rare glimpse into Kevin Rudd the man, not the puppet.

The $14,000 collection, which we taxpayers fund, is housed at the PM's official residences - The Lodge in Canberra and Kirribilli House in Sydney - and is scattered with some spectacular drops.

But by and large, the roughly 600-bottle cellar reflects his rather dull, try-hard approach that is becoming more prevalent by the day.

See Rudd's wine cellar list here.

To be fair to Rudd, the old stuff in the cellar heralds from the Howard years - sauvignon blancs and viogniers from the mid-2000s that would be well past their best now. Plus a 1985 Dom Perignon, purchased for just $99.95 thank you very much.

But there is a distinct lack of inspiration in recent acquisitions, with smaller, family-run wineries and boutique producers nowhere to be seen, while all but one of (Japanese-owned) Lion Nathan's wine brands make the list. Hmmmmm.

It's also blatantly clear that Rudd is a white man, not a red. If only I knew that little fact before the last election.

There's no shortage of West Australian flavour in the cellar, with the PM particularly keen on Sandalford and Houghton's Pemberton Sauvignon Blanc 2006 (33 bottles at $18.35 each).

But other large quantities of wine are similarly uninspiring for a PM's personal stash: 46 x Blue Pyrenees NV Brut ($22.75), 43 x Alto Pinot Grigio 2008 ($20.91), 36 x Mr Riggs Shiraz ($18) and 42 x Kangarilla Road 2006 Fleurieu ($17.27).

Two bottles of St Hallet Old Block Shiraz 2003 ($52.03), eight bottles of Petaluma Merlot 04 ($47.42), plus a couple of big Henschkes from the early 2000s are the only real decent reds with age that would be ripe drinking right now.

Perhaps the PM is saving them for Kerry Stokes.

And if John Howard ever pops in for a Wallabies game and some cheese and crackers, Rudd could open one of the seven Edwards and Chaffey 99 Shiraz bottles ($27.23) that Little Johnny kindly left behind. They'd be close to off by now.

(I do take pleasure in knowing I purchased six bottles of the exact wine from a Perth bottleshop about 2001 for $23, cheaper than our PM paid.)

Perhaps most worrying about the list is the 11 Centenary Federation 1999 red magnums ($86.36), a wine blended from premium grapes from Australia's then 61 wine regions, with 150 bottles intended as gifts for heads of state throughout the world and at Commonwealth celebrations in 2001.

Clearly we left some important people off the list, and who knows how and when that might come back to bite us.

At least Kevin will have a good excuse. That's if he's not punch drunk on one of his six bottles of 2008 NZ sauvignon blanc ($13.31).

As Little Johnny would say, that's a bit un-Australian.

What do you think of the PM's wine cellar? Comment below or email here.

31 comments so far

  • Just like his new policy on payroll tax.......... the guy's an absolute loser with no idea how to run a profitable nation........... cant wait to get rid of him.

    Commenter
    Leah
    Date and time
    February 19, 2010, 9:40AM
  • It is pretty poor. Also notice that a lot of our good Australian Owned, Australian Run, family winemakers (like Angove Family Winemakers) are not represented yet the likes of the Kiwi (now Japanese Brewer) Lion Nathans portfolio gets a fair smattering with Bridgewater Mill, Petaluma, Croser, St Hallet, Knappstein, Smithbrook, Stonier and Mitchelton all on the list (only one of their portfolio missing is Tatachilla).

    Commenter
    Matt
    Location
    Perth
    Date and time
    February 19, 2010, 10:01AM
  • nice one. it's sad that he's not taking advantage of what must be one of the best perks about being PM - the right to have a cellar brimming with top-notch wines. it's like he sent a staffer to load up a trolley at dan murphy's one afternoon.

    Commenter
    Ruth
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    February 19, 2010, 10:00AM
  • How our PM can have a cellar without the iconic Grange, or any Penfolds (one of our finest producers) for that matter, is incredible.

    Commenter
    Dave
    Date and time
    February 19, 2010, 10:03AM
  • What were you expecting?
    I am not at all surprised!
    Krudds cellar is a perfect reflection of himself – dull,boring and not much imagination.
    You would think that he would be wanting to serve the very best of Australia’s wine to visiting dignitaries  and guests.
    What does he do? stocks up on NZ Savvy!

    Commenter
    Ken
    Location
    Hunter Valley
    Date and time
    February 19, 2010, 2:32PM
  • Begs the question.
    What would be the perfect wine cellar with $14,000 to spend?

    Commenter
    Stewart
    Date and time
    February 19, 2010, 2:35PM
  • I understood the PM contracts a "consultant" to stock his cellar?

    Instead of forking out Consultancy fees, He can get all the help he needs from top100wines.com

    Commenter
    Warren
    Location
    New South Wales
    Date and time
    February 21, 2010, 1:04PM
  • if you're going to put any savvy in the cellar, you might as well buy the best there is......hence the kiwi stuff!!

    Commenter
    tapz
    Location
    Melb
    Date and time
    February 22, 2010, 10:28AM
  • Bland. Just like the man, the Party and the policies.

    Commenter
    prLAB
    Location
    Perth
    Date and time
    February 22, 2010, 11:07AM
  • Here comes "Winewatch"." By 2020 no Australia should have to drink bland wine"

    Commenter
    Gen X
    Date and time
    February 22, 2010, 12:37PM

More comments

Make a comment

You are logged in as [Logout]

All information entered below may be published.

Error: Please enter your screen name.

Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Please enter your comment.

Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

Post to

You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

Thank you

Your comment has been submitted for approval.

Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

More Related Coverage

Gettin' fizzy with it

12 Feb Once upon a time I cringed at the thought of drinking red wine that was fizzy and cold, but the fact is Australian winemakers have started producing stuff that's worth trying, and sticking to.

A pinot in my pantry

5 Feb After the financial excesses of Christmas, David Prestipino finds some winners in the bargain bin of his local bottle shop.

Nothing petit about this

11 Mar Lick your lips, because straight petit verdot is starting to gain real momentum in Australian vineyards - and at Bellarmine in Pemberton, they've nailed it already.

Our whining politicians

26 Feb It'd be remiss of me not to stay with the political theme this week.

Getting lost in the Woods

18 Mar Thanks to Tiger Woods, I have just experienced probably the silliest hangover in my many over the years.

The 20 trends to avoid in 2010

25 Mar OJ with bubbly? Ice with white wine? Not any more... see the 20 trends to avoid in 2010.

Fine wine for prime cuts

2 Apr David Prestipino gets some advice on matching wine with prime cuts of beef from Rockpool sommelier David Lawler.

Masters of Wine

8 Apr On the occasion of Tiger Woods's return to golf, David Prestipino gives out his own Masters of Wine awards.

Cellar the moment

15 Apr A wine cellar is a place of sanctuary, of stories and more often than not, of some great bottles of wine.

Hold the Penfolds

23 Apr Penfolds make some of the most popular, reliable and iconic wines in Australia. Here's what its new releases taste like.

Mum's the word

6 May David Prestipino's wine and champagne picks for Mother's Day.

Wine school part I

20 May Wine appreciation courses can be hit or miss. If you've ever been to one, you know that you can only learn as much as your wine master allows.

Wrestling with the Heart Foundation

13 May David Prestipino ponders the implications of the Heart Foundation's findings on red wine and antioxidants.

The secrets of terroir

27 May There's no doubt the land from which grapes are grown impart a unique quality to a wine specific to that region. What we don't know is the amount of influence and scope terroir has on the particular wines.

Plantagenet powers on

3 Jun Vine variation is alive and well at Plantagenet.

Inspecting gadgets

1 Jul There's a go-go-gadget for almost every wine experience. But are they actually useful?

Say cheese please

17 Jun Love a little cheese with your wine? Who doesn't. Now matching wine and cheese is made easy.

Glass Matters

17 Jun The shape of your glass will either detract or enhance the flavour of your wine.

Serious red night

10 Jun With winter now upon us, there's no better time to get reacquainted with red wine.

Tax on the poor man

30 Apr How a new tax on wine could hit your wallet.

Words of Wisdom

8 Jul The latest Wisdom wines at Houghton are a smart bunch to seek out.